The plaque it o.k., but kinda boring.

If you give out a flag (which I really like!), get decent flags like the one Steven has in his photo / signature. I've seen some clubs/regions give out small cheesy ones. They look like kiddie flags.

I also like the cup (like the smiley trophy) or pimp challace as some of my friends call it. For that event, in addition to the flag and cup, they also gave out champagne. Now mind you it may not have been very good champagne (I have no idea as it sits next to the trophy unopened), but still very cool.

For the Spooktacular event...anything you can think of kinda related? A racing pumpkin figure?