Since these are mystery cars, a critical factor has not been established that, given the weight range of these cars and everything else equal, easily tilts the favor one way or the other. So which wheels are putting the power down on both cars? Assuming both are fwd, then definitely the lighter #1. If both are rwd, based solely on those specs alone they seem pretty even imo, but out of personal preference I'd probably take the heavier car #2 with more tq.